OpenAI Fights Order to Turn Over 20 Million Chats
By Reuters | 12 Nov, 2025

Complying with the order would jeopardize confidential user information and the information is 99.99% irrelevant to the New York Times copyright infringement suit, according to OpenAI's motion to reverse the court order.

OpenAI asked a federal judge in New York on Wednesday to reverse an order that required it to turn over 20 million anonymized ChatGPT chat logs amid a copyright infringement lawsuit by the New York Times and other news outlets, saying it would expose users' private conversations.

The artificial intelligence company argued that turning over the logs would disclose confidential user information and that "99.99%" of the transcripts have nothing to do with the copyright infringement allegations in the case. 

"To be clear: anyone in the world who has used ChatGPT in the past three years must now face the possibility that their personal conversations will be handed over to The Times to sift through at will in a speculative fishing expedition," the company said in a court filing.

LAWSUIT CLAIMS OPENAI MISUSED TIMES STORIES

The news outlets argued that the logs were necessary to determine whether ChatGPT reproduced their copyrighted content and to rebut OpenAI's assertion that they "hacked" the chatbot's responses to manufacture evidence. The lawsuit claims OpenAI misused their articles to train ChatGPT to respond to user prompts.

Magistrate Judge Ona Wang said in her order to produce the chats that users' privacy would be protected by the company's "exhaustive de-identification" and other safeguards. OpenAI has a Friday deadline to produce the transcripts.

OpenAI Chief Information Security Officer Dane Stuckey said in a blog post on Wednesday that sharing the logs would violate privacy and security protections and "force us to turn over tens of millions of highly personal conversations from people who have no connection to the Times’ baseless lawsuit."

A New York Times spokesperson said OpenAI's blog post "purposely misleads its users and omits the facts."

"No ChatGPT user’s privacy is at risk," the spokesperson said. "The court ordered OpenAI to provide a sample of chats, anonymized by OpenAI itself, under a legal protective order."

The OpenAI case is one of many pending lawsuits against tech companies over the alleged misuse of copyrighted work to train AI systems. 

(Reporting by Blake Brittain in WashingtonEditing by Rod Nickel)